Medical Decisions

Decision Information

Decision Content

 

GENERAL INFORMATION

KEYWORDS

Category 3 aviation medical certificate, neurological disorder

FILE NO.

O-2015-01

SECTOR (Marine or Aviation)

Aviation

SPECIFIC JOB

Private pilot

DIAGNOSIS (Primary, Secondary, etc.)

Diffuse Brain Dysfunction

REVIEW

DATE OF DETERMINATION

September 25, 2000

MEMBER

Samuel J. Birenbaum

DETERMINATION

The Minister of Transport’s decision not to renew the applicant’s aviation medical certificate is confirmed.

REASONS FOR THE DETERMINATION

Refusal to renew a category 3 aviation medical certificate — The applicant, after a long delay, did provide the Minister of Transport (Minister) with psychological reports, but never with the requested psychiatric reports. The psychological reports consistently demonstrate impairment of cognitive function, not reversible, and no improvement is likely in the future. This level of impaired cognition is incompatible with aviation safety. The applicant did not offer any evidence to dispute this fact. The Minister’s representatives have fulfilled their role in not renewing the applicant’s aviation medical certificate, and by doing so, have protected the safety of all, especially that of the applicant himself. For these reasons, the Minister’s decision not to renew the applicant’s aviation medical certificate is confirmed.

APPEAL

DATE OF DECISION

 

MEMBERS

 

DECISION

 

REASONS FOR THE DECISION

 

OTHER/COMMENTS

 

 

 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.