Medical Decisions

Decision Information

Decision Content

 

GENERAL INFORMATION

KEYWORDS

Mental health, psychotic illness, psychiatric disorder, Schizophrenia

FILE NO.

P-2982-01

SECTOR (Marine or Aviation)

Aviation

SPECIFIC JOB

Private pilot

DIAGNOSIS (Primary, Secondary, etc.)

Schizophrenic-form disorder

REVIEW

DATE OF DETERMINATION

August 6, 2004

MEMBER

David S. Ahmed

DETERMINATION

The Minister of Transport’s decision not to renew the applicant’s aviation medical certificate is confirmed.

REASONS FOR THE DETERMINATION

Refusal to renew an aviation medical certificate — The applicant was committed to a psychiatric hospital following some bizarre behaviour. He spent three weeks in the psychiatric hospital and was discharged with a final diagnosis of schizophrenic‑form disorder. He was put on medication for this and it was urgently recommended that he remain in care and receive treatment for his psychosis. Subsequently, Transport Canada (TC) lifted his medical certificate. It was also noted that the applicant rejected the idea that he had a mental disorder. Based on the evidence, the member concluded that the Minister of Transport was able to prove, based on the opinion of three separate psychiatrists, that the applicant did suffer a psychotic illness in 1997. The applicant did not bring any evidence forward to show any proof that this was not the case. The member advised the applicant that he could not accept his own opinion regarding his psychiatric state but any new information that may come from a psychiatrist or psychiatrists should be submitted to TC for consideration. The Minister’s decision not to renew his aviation medical certificate is confirmed.

APPEAL

DATE OF DECISION

 

MEMBERS

 

DECISION

 

REASONS FOR THE DECISION

 

OTHER/COMMENTS

 

 

 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.